A self-evaluation system that only produces reassuring results is not evidence of a strong school - it is usually evidence of a system leadership has not yet learned to distrust.

Three warning signs are worth checking for directly. A system that never surfaces a genuinely uncomfortable finding is more likely under-designed than the school is over-performing. A system where the same small group both collects and interprets the evidence has no natural check against confirmation bias - strong self-evaluation separates who gathers evidence from who is accountable for what it shows. And a system that produces data no one revisits between review cycles is a reporting exercise, not an evaluation system - the test of self-evaluation is whether it changes a decision, not whether it generates a document.

Leadership does not need a larger self-evaluation system to trust it more. It needs one built to occasionally tell them something they did not want to hear - and a governance rhythm that treats that finding as useful information rather than a problem to be managed away before the next board meeting.